What a wonderful site this is.
I had to respond to the question: Why does Tinker respond by cutting Carl into pieces? It's very situation specific: First, he makes Carl betray Rod with words and cuts out his tongue so he can't speak anymore. Then, after he watches Carl try to communicate with Rod by writing, he cuts off Carl's hands so he can't write anymore. Then, after he watches Carl dance for Rod, he cuts off Carl's feet so he can't dance anymore. I read this as silencing, that Tinker is silencing Carl in the same way we silence each other, e.g., racism is not a topic we should discuss because it's so incendiary, despite the fact that racism underlies the entire foundation of our country (U.S.). In a way, it seems that Tinker does not want Carl to connect with Rod, though I can't say I've thought that out as well as the reason I believe Tinker is chopping Carl up.
Archive 20-2-2002